selection bias and the benefits of hovering

new study shows students with involved parents do better but

they get lower grades on average.

Huh?

Well, it makes sense.
Basically, involved parents go to helicopter mode when the students are struggling, over-reaching or just need a nudge.

So there are three classes of students:
those which do well, independent of parent involvement
those which do better than they would, because the parents are involved
and, those which do badly and don't get parental assistance

these are not exclusive or exhaustive

National Survey of Student Engagement

Another interesting point is the report that students benefit (at least internally) from "high impact" activity. Where they are pushed to engage with each other or faculty.
This makes sense, and is important to know - these activities are high cost and there is continual debate about whether to sustain such activities.

Tags

More like this

That's shocking mostly in a Claude-Rains-in-Casablanca sort of sense ("I am shocked--shocked!"), but there are a couple of stories in Inside Higher Ed this morning presenting new findings that seem like they ought to be really obvious. The first is a new study of the University of California system…
Steven Pinker has a piece at the New Republic arguing that Ivy League schools ought to weight standardized test scores more heavily in admissions. this has prompted a bunch of tongue-clucking about the failures of the Ivy League from the usual suspects, and a rather heated concurrence from Scott…
In education school, I was taught that the purpose of grading was to rank-order students -- to create a system whereby the highest-achieving students were ranked at the top and the lowest-achieving students were at the bottom. But recently there have been worries that grade inflation is making it…
There's a paper in the Journal of Political Economy that has sparked a bunch of discussion. The article, bearing the snappy title "Does Professor Quality Matter? Evidence from Random Assignment of Students to Professors," looks at the scores of over 10,000 students at the US Air Force Academy over…

Ah, I know why this is (I think).

You see, involved parents mostly cater to their kids whims. So kid doesn't want to read? Mom will buy them the shortest possible school assigned book AND the Cliff Notes.

They want their kids to get the grade without necessarily having to do the work. This does less well when they hit the university.

By cptnapalm (not verified) on 05 Nov 2007 #permalink