Worker does not infer from mtDNA alone....

Evolgen has a nice little post up on the problems with mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) in regards to using it to infer demographic history. This form of genomic information is useful in that it is relatively copious, being present in the hundreds of mitochondrion to be found within every cell. This is one reason that the early work on molecular clocks in the context of paleoanthropology used mtDNA, you needed a lot of raw material in the pre-PCR era. Remember mitochondrial Eve?

Now that neat story is fallling apart as the reality that mtDNA is subject to a great deal of selection seems to be clear, and selection tends to distort the coalescent methodology which lay at the heart of these clock models. All this is a prelim for what I really want to highlight, John Hawks enormous review titled Selection, nuclear genetic variation, and mtDNA. I would say that John was a selectionist before selectionism was sexy...but well, if some of you know the history of evolutionary biology, that doesn't seem to work right....

Tags

More like this

I've always had an interest in human origins, and have been an avid consumer of books and papers relating to the emergence of our own species through an evolutionary lens. Though I am interested in paleontology, my own bias has been to look toward the genetic evidence because it is more accessible…
The idea of stochastic training wheels sounds a bit scary, but I am alluding to the series of posts on stochastic dynamics adapted from chapter 5 of Evolutionary Genetics: Concepts & Case Studies by John Gillespie. Using Gillespie's terminology the posts were: Boundary Process Origination…
John Noble Wilford in The New York Times has a piece titled The Human Family Tree Has Become a Bush With Many Branches, which reflects the current consensus thinking that the hominid lineage was until recently relatively diversified, with a host of species extant contemporaneously (the other view…
Marriage, we're told by the president and a lot of other people, can only be between one man and one woman. Anything else would go against thousands of years of tradition and nature itself. If the president's DNA could talk, I think it might disagree. In the 1980s, geneticists began to study…