Doonesbury on magical thinking

Getting it right once again (click on the image for the whole comic)...

i-6347238552303058957e5928fa42939b-db071223a.gif

I've been meaning to do a piece about Head On, but I think I've decided that it's just too ridiculous to bother with, and that's saying something. After all, this is the blog that regularly posts pictures of a giant enema bottle.

More like this

A few of my recent posts here appear to have struck some nerves, and I've been getting lots of annoying email containing the same questions, over and over again. So rather than reply individually, I'm going to answer them here in the hope that either (a) people will see the answers before send the…
It's that time of year again. What am I talking about? Regular readers know. They know that sometime around the Memorial Day weekend every year, usually beginning a couple of days before the extended weekend and into the weekend itself, there lands in the Chicago area a quackfest of such…
Has it really been that long? It was a dismally overcast Saturday five years ago when, on a whim after having read a TIME Magazine article about how 2004 was supposedly the Year of the Blogger, I sat down in front of my computer, found Blogspot, and the first incarnation of Respectful Insolence…
Since this seems to be the day for applying Respectful Insolence⢠to people who say stupid things about me... Everyone knows that Dean Esmay and I don't exactly see eye to eye on a lot of things. Indeed, it could be safely said that Dean has nothing but contempt for me. It doesn't bother me. After…

I wish somebody would put an ad right behind theirs, reminding people that the product they just saw is nothing more than a wax stick. But... Wishing is more magical thinking.
(joke) Oh well, perhaps after I win the lottery (/joke)

But the important question is when are you going to debunk homework?

What I find truly impressive about Head On is its ability to con people into thinking that it is effective *without even saying what it's supposed to be for*!

Now that's impressive. (On the other hand, it's been done before. Shades of "Cuforhedake", or whatever it was called, back when the government first started to crack down on blatantly false claims.)

By Calli Arcalempre (not verified) on 23 Dec 2007 #permalink

I just think it's funny that the comic has a priest talking about "magical thinking".

Bohemian Road Nurse had a great post a year or so ago,describing an elderly home care patient who reported relief of her headaches with a product applied directly to the forehead. When asked if it were HeadOn, the patient responded that it was similar, but that she purchased the cheaper generic version. She then produced for the nurse's inspection a bottle of Ban Roll-on deodorant.

I have a small pot of headache balm made primarily of menthol and lavendar, which does help my sinus headaches...well, the menthol bit does. It clears up my nose some and relieves the pressure. But I also know what's in it and how it works, and it only works for those headaches (not my migraines, for example). Head-on, on the other hand...